• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

The New Taste of Italy – Authentic Italian Flavors & Warm Family Atmosphere in Silver Lake, WI

The New Taste of Italy in Silver Lake, WI, offers an inviting, family-run dining experience that redefines casual Italian cuisine. Known for its fresh, hearty dishes like Chicken Alfredo, Italian beef, and shrimp diavola, this spot balances generous portions with affordable prices. The warm, attentive staff enhance the welcoming atmosphere, making every visit feel personal. Highlights include fresh bread sticks, crispy fries, and robust house Chianti wine. Whether after a lake ride or a casual night out, the quality, flavor, and relaxed vibe here make it a must-try for Italian food lovers seeking authenticity without pretension.

The New Taste of Italy at a glance

  • Address 101 S 2nd St, Silver Lake, WI 53170, United States
  • Phone +1 262-889-2429
  • Restaurant type Italian restaurant .
  • Popular for Lunch , Dinner , Solo dining .

Photos & Gallery

The New Taste of Italy: Reviews & Ratings

Andrew Ziebel
5

What an exceptional experience and I didn’t even get to dine in yet. The Chicken Alfredo is amazing, fresh bread, crunchy salad and good ranch dressing. I will definitely be eating here more often.

Marie
5

This place is amazing. My favorite meal was the ribs with potatoes and a side of coleslaw. I personally think this is my new favorite restaurant. Something that caught me a little off guard was the caned sodas but they’re only $1.50 compared to all these other bars that go for Around three dollars. I honestly think it’s a a cleaner way to serve soda. The prices are very low, considering the large amount of good quality food. Don’t even get me started on the amazing staff! They’re super attentive and kind. Definitely one of the hardest working servers I’ve seen. The atmosphere is very welcoming considering it’s a family owned restaurant and the whole family is working. They welcome you as if you are a part of it. Definitely check it out. I never leave reviews and I just had to leave a review for this one.

Rachel
5

11/10. No words to describe the food here, it’s so good. Everything from their salads to a chicken parm, shrimp diavala, Italian beef’s and pizza too. Personally have tried them all, and all outstanding. The staff is very timely and accommodating. Super chill atmosphere

Claire Rodriguez
5

This is my favorite place to come to after a long bike ride around the lake. The staff always take such great care of us. Food is superb! The carbonara is a family favorite as well as the Italian beef. The French fries are also perfectly crispy. The house Chianti is a great wine. Overall this is a place where you can expect to relax and eat great food and drink great wine.

heather pisano
4

Definitely not as "fancy" as the original Taste of Italy. No more white tablecloths and more casual feel BUT the food was delicious, starting with the famous bread sticks. I had the Manicotti special which was fresh and so tasty. My fiancé had the Fettuccini Alfredo and was very happy with it. Would definitely recommend to locals! Did I mention the LARGE pours of wine?! Lol

See Vids
5

EXCELLENT homemade Italian cuisine at this family-owned neighborhood restaurant that is 'off the charts' delicious! We ordered lasagna, pasta w/red sauce & lg meatball, and shrimp florentine -- OMG!...so satisfyingly good! They offered complimentary fresh-baked bread sticks and have a wine list for every palette. What an awesome find! This is now on our 'go to' list of restaurants and highly recommend to anyone who relishes really good fresh & authentic Italian food. Cozy atmosphere, friendly staff, generous portions, affordable prices, and like I said ... their food is EXCELLENT! Big thumbs up!

Danielle Duha
5

We absolutely loved this place! The new owners have done such a wonderful job! The food was outstanding! Everything is homemade and they are extremely passionate about the quality of the food! We had to wait a bit for table and they were so accommodating! They brought us a round of drinks and brought coloring books out for our kids! Our server was so sweet and attentive! At the end of our meal the owners came out to talk to us and even took our kids for a tour of the kitchen where they let them make a mini pizza in a shape of a heart! In a world full of chaos, they have created such a loving atmosphere! We will be back!!!

Location

  • The New Taste of Italy
    The New Taste of Italy
    101 S 2nd St, Silver Lake, WI 53170, United States Hotline: +1 262-889-2429

Discovering "The New Taste of Italy" in Silver Lake, Wisconsin, is like stepping into a warm embrace of authentic Italian flavors paired with a relaxed, family-run atmosphere. This restaurant captures the essence of Italian cuisine with dishes that are both hearty and fresh, offering a new twist on beloved classics.

The first thing that strikes you is the generous portions and thoughtful attention to quality. Take the Chicken Alfredo, praised for its rich sauce and complemented by fresh bread and crisp salads. The balance of flavors and textures here creates a fulfilling experience that invites repeat visits. The ribs with potatoes and coleslaw stand out as a comfort meal done right, offering a satisfying contrast in both taste and presentation.

Italian staples shine through every plate. The chicken parmigiana, shrimp diavola, and Italian beef showcase the kitchen’s dedication to depth and authenticity, while the perfectly crispy fries and house Chianti elevate the dining experience beyond mere sustenance. The carbonara and manicotti specials express traditional techniques with a fresh, approachable feel, reflecting the familial touch that runs through this establishment.

The atmosphere is genuine and welcoming, shaped by the hardworking family behind the scenes and the attentive staff on the floor. Customers appreciate how the casual vibe replaces formality without losing the integrity of Italian dining. The affordability—like sodas priced at a wallet-friendly $1.50—and large pours of house wine make this spot a rare find for quality and value.

In sum, "The New Taste of Italy" is a gem that delivers more than just food; it offers comfort, community, and an honest celebration of Italian culinary traditions made accessible. Each dish is a story, each bite a memory, making it a place where you not only eat well but feel at home.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Wheelchair-accessible car park
  • Service options
    • Delivery
    • Takeaway
    • Dine-in
  • Payments
    • Credit cards